What Ever Happened To Toms Shoes
Jordyn Holman and Margaret Sutherlin, Bloomberg News
— Toms, the once-high-flying shoe brand, is itching for a comeback.
It starts with expanding beyond the millennials who swooned for its slip-ons and how it donated a pair of shoes to a needy kid for each one sold. To connect with todays teens and early 20-somethingsa group dubbed Generation Zthe brand has ended the footwear donations that keyed its breakthrough a decade ago and is now giving a third of profit to causes it says this younger cohort cares about, such as gun violence. Marketing has been revamped to focus on teens. Its also pushing further into sneakers.
This is all part of the brands bid to rebound from a remarkable fall that saw it sink from being touted in Vogue and worn by celebs such as Snoop Dogg and Anne Hathaway to being mismanaged by private equity into near-collapsecreditors took control of the debt-laden company in December 2019. Magnus Wedhammar, a former Nike and Converse executive, arrived shortly thereafter as CEO to clean up the mess.
Theres no secret that over the last four or five years Toms has gone through a revenue decline, Wedhammar said. But the brand still has decent name recognition, he said. Most Gen Zs are aware of Toms.
Moving away from one-to-one is a big thing for Toms because we were sort of the pioneer of that movement, said Amy Smith, Tomss chief strategy and impact officer.
How Toms Shoes Makes Profit From A Cause
TOMS Shoes business model is called one-for-one. It means that for each pair of shoes sold, the company gives one pair back to kids in developing countries. The one-for-one model allows the company to monetize through consumers word of mouth and social campaigns, with a minimum effort in terms of sales and marketing.
The Reality Of Running A Business
Heres what seems to have happened:
Facing criticism and questions about their shoe giveaways, Toms decided to commission a thorough study, which they genuinely believed would show children benefiting.
These arent evil people. The founder seems like a decent man who wanted to believe, and did believe, he could get rich by doing good. Who doesnt want to believe that? He had been telling the public for seven years that you can help a child in need. Surely he believed it too.
They found qualified researchers who explained that to be taken seriously, a research study should file its plan in advance and agree to make full results public.
Toms, confident the results would look good, agreed.
Then the disappointing results arrived. Toms Shoes couldnt hide the report, but it didnt have to publicize it, either. So Toms did some tinkering in addition to shoes, it got involved in water, vision, safe births, and preventing bullying. Anyone aware of the study now saw a fuzzier picture. Perhaps the shoe giveaway wasnt so good, but it was only a small part of all the things that Toms did. It was still possible to make a better world through shopping.
Meanwhile, their promotional materials ignore the hard facts of the independent study they commissioned, and they find ways to spin the vague and self-interested reports from their partners. As a business, theyd probably collapse if they did it any other way.
You May Like: Can I Wash Hey Dude Shoes
The Rise And Fall Of The Buy
It would be wrong to say TOMS shoes invented the Buy-One-Give-One model when it hit the market in 2006, but students of purpose marketing would agree that it quickly became the best-known company associated with that form of embedded giving.
That is why it struck so many so hard when TOMS which had gone into such a steep business decline that it almost went bankrupt in 2019 announced recently that it had completely moved away from linking the sale of its shoes to giving shoes to poor people
Ive followed the rise and fall of TOMSs BOGO program with great interest over the years. For most consumers the great appeal of TOMS was the apparent simplicity of the offering you buy a pair of shoes, we give a pair to a person in need. But it didnt take a very deep study of the LA-based company to realize that giving away shoes on a mass level was anything but simple.
During the early years when the TOMS story took off like a rocket and its BOGO story electrifyied millions of consumers, TOMS tried to keep out of the spotlight the fact that it was having tremendous difficulty giving away as many shoes as it was selling. Instead of being transparent, the website was very scant on details. The TOMS team discovered early on, as founder Blake Mycoskie later told me, Giving is really hard.
Master roaster at TOMS Angel Orozco and founder of TOMS Blake Mycoskie attend TOMS’ Austin Store … Opening on March 11, 2014 in Austin, Texas.
What Is The Advocacy Of Blake Mycoskie
TOMS Founder Blake Mycoskie Encourages Self-Help After Depression Diagnosis. LAS VEGASBlake Mycoskie, the founder of TOMS, proved to the world that giving is good for business. By donating to those in need with each customer purchase, he started a movement 13 years ago that other companies have followed.
You May Like: What Shoes To Wear With Mom Jeans Winter
Toms Shoes Creditors To Take Over The Company
- Toms Shoes creditors have agreed to take over the maker of casual footwear in exchange for restructuring its debt, according to a company letter sent to employees on Friday and people familiar with the matter.
- The group of creditors will take over ownership of Toms from its founder Blake Mycoskie and private equity firm Bain Capital.
- Bain had acquired a 50% stake in Toms five years ago, valuing the company at $625 million, including debt.
Toms Shoes creditors have agreed to take over the maker of casual footwear in exchange for restructuring its debt, according to a company letter sent to employees on Friday and people familiar with the matter.
The group of creditors, led by Jefferies Financial Group, Nexus Capital Management and Brookfield Asset Management, will take over ownership of Toms from its founder Blake Mycoskie and private equity firm Bain Capital, according to the letter. In exchange, the creditors will provide debt relief to the company, according to the sources, who requested anonymity to discuss confidential arrangements.
Bain had acquired a 50% stake in Toms five years ago, valuing the company at $625 million, including debt. Mycoskie owned the remainder. It is not yet clear whether Mycoskie will continue to have a role with the company given that he will no longer be an owner.
The new owners have agreed to invest $35 million in Toms to show their commitment and support its future growth, according to the letter.
Colonialism Means The Rich Country Comes First
Toms Shoes didnt begin by asking, What is best for children or anyone else in poorer countries? It asked, How can we get what we want profits and free publicity while at the same time everybody looks good and feels good? Needy children were just the resource it needed.
Intrinsic to karma colonialism is the idea of a win-win approach. Thats what this looked like at first. Toms made money, consumers got to shop and feel good, needy children got shoes.
But win-win doesnt work when one side holds all the power. When it turned out that the poor kids were getting a bad deal, all that mattered was that the real winners Toms and the consumers were able to feel, provided they didnt look too closely, that it was still win-win.
Recommended Reading: What Is A Shoe Raffle
Are Toms Shoes Made In China
Original TOMS shoes are made in Haiti, China, Ethiopia, and Argentina, but this is not indicated or printed on any part of the shoe. The company has committed to producing one-third of its shoes in the regions where they are donated. The small tag should only be printed with the brand TOMS and nothing else.
Get Your Entire Team On Board With Changes
If your proposed changes to any efforts are truly a positive step in your mission, it’s critical to have the morale of yourself and your staff behind you–especially your marketing team. “You have to believe in what you’re doing and you need to have leadership buy-in,” Smith said. “You need to be able to tell your story effectively, and that’s heavy lifting and hard work.”
Get Inc.s top posts straight to your inbox. and youll receive Todays Must Reads before each day is done.
You May Like: Dress Sandals For Wide Feet
Report: Toms Shoes Creditors Will Take Over Business From Founder
Credit ratings agencies including Moodys had warned that TOMS, which is known for its charitable giving and One for One shoe donation model, would not have been able to repay a $306.5 million loan due in October 2020 without renegotiations with its creditors. Both Moodys and Fitch Ratings had said that chances were high that Toms would default on its debt this year.
The group of creditors, led by Jefferies Financial Group Inc., Nexus Capital Management LP and Brookfield Asset Management Inc., will take over ownership of TOMS from Founder Blake Mycoskie and private equity firm Bain Capital, according to the report. Mycoskie and Bain each own a 50% share in the retailer. Bain had acquired its 50% stake in TOMS in 2014 for $313 million, valuing the company at $625 million, including debt.
It is not yet clear whether Mycoskie will continue to have a role with the company, given that he will no longer be an owner.
To support growth, the creditors are investing $35 million into TOMS and restructuring its balance sheet, according to CEO Jim Alling.
Ethical Shoe Brand Toms Hopes To Find Its Footing With Gen Z
After a tough couple of years, the firm has a new philanthropic focus and a new look for the summer
Ethical shoe brand Toms hit the big time by making shoppers feel good about buying shoes as it donated a pair of its canvas espadrilles every time it banked a sale. But then consumers stopped buying.
Now the US brand is on the comeback trail with a different profit-sharing setup and a new image. A chunky soled version of its slip-ons, aimed at Gen Z-ers cool enough to wear them with their socks pulled up, will hit the shops this summer.
Toms one-for-one shoe-giving promise, where it worked with humanitarian organisations to give a pair to children in poverty, has been replaced with a commitment to give a third of its profits to non-profit grassroots organisations, says Magnus Wedhammar, who joined as chief executive in 2020. This is as much as it can give away while still keeping the lights on with grants directed to community groups promoting mental health, trying to end gun violence and improving access to education.
Theres no secret that over the last couple of years Toms has struggled and we were in decline, says Wedhammar. It still shifts about $250m a year but is trying to attract a new generation of customers more interested in ethical shopping than their parents.
Young shoppers are particularly interested in ethical brands that take a stand on issues but it has become harder for companies to stand out in a crowded marketplace.
Don’t Miss: How To Clean Mold Off Leather Shoes
Why Is Blake Mycoskie Successful
Mycoskie has persevered through this hardship. He has said that by providing children with pairs of shoes, they can go to school. By getting an education the children will be able to learn and one day build a successful career which would help the recipients of the shoes build a self-sustaining life .
The Toms Reboot: Shoe Disruptor Regains Its Footing By Taking Bold New Steps
The brand has ended its buy-a-pair, give-a-pair pledge and is looking to attract younger consumers with a new charitable model and a new shoe.
After years spent in a decline, footwear brand Toms is turning things aroundmodernizing its offerings and refocusing its charitable giving model.
Also Check: Sell Shoes Fast
Youre Pretty Smart But Poor People Know More About Their Needs Than You Do
Theres a different approach. Instead of giving shoes, why not give poor people cash? If shoes are really what the recipients need, then they can go ahead and buy them. But if not, their options are wide open: They can put the money toward medicine or a crop loan or school fees. Or they can use it to invest in some kind of income-generating venture, such as livestock or a small business.
If youre like most people, youre probably feeling some discomfort with that idea. If you give shoes to a kid, then at least you know the kid has shoes. But if you give money, whats to stop it from being wasted?
The message of TOMS-style giving is that its fine for you to make the decision about what the recipient needs, because you are smart and know whats best. Thats an appealing message, because it carries all kinds of really flattering implications about how clever and responsible you are, and it puts you in control. But research very strongly suggests that in addition to being condescending, its a bad way to run an aid program.
Take, for instance, a recent study by Columbia political science professor Chris Blattman. He and his team ran an experiment that gave poor women in northern Uganda cash to start small businesses. One group got cash plus expert advice on starting a business, but a comparison group got cash alone. After a year, both groups were doing better.
In the meantime: Your TOMS shoes look great with that outfit. But they’re not going to save the world.
Now When You Make A Purchase You Can Have The Shoe Company Support Solutions For One Of Five Different Issues Of Course Giving A Pair Of Shoes Is Still An Option
When Toms launched in 2006, it popularized the one-for-one business model by giving away a free pair of shoes for every pair sold. Its success helped inspire a series of other buy-one, give-one businesses, from Warby Parker to State Bags. But the companys model for giving is evolving: If you buy a pair of shoes on the Toms website or in one of the companys stores now, youll be given a choice of a cause to support. Giving shoes is still an option, but you can also choose womens rights or ending gun violence, and instead of products Toms will give a grant to a nonprofit working on that area.
Over the last year and a half or so, weve really been reflecting on where might we have the greatest impact, says Amy Smith, the chief giving officer for Toms. What is changing in the world around us? In 2018, the company launched its first campaign to end gun violence with a $5 million donation and asking Americans to send postcards to Congress. The new direction for giving, launched May 7, will let consumers support similar campaigns in five issue areas: safe water, ending gun violence, homelessness, mental health, or equality.
Toms is proud of spurring the explosion of one-for-one businesses, Smith says. But as we continue to innovate, we hope that people follow as well. And I hope, collectively, that purpose-driven companies are always questioning, are we having the greatest impact possible?
Recommended Reading: Stuart Weitzman Narrow Shoes
Toms Needs Needy Children
Toms Shoes needs needy children or, at least, children who can be portrayed as needy. It is using them for their ability to be depicted as children in need.
How different is that from the industrialists of a century ago who needed iron and tin, found a source in a poor and powerless country, and took the resource that helped them make a profit? There is a transaction. The richer and more powerful partner sets the terms, and decides whether to continue it, change it, or drop it. The rich get richer, the poor get more dependent but its hidden under a veneer of good karma.
Like an INGO, Toms Shoes has created a strategy that works for Toms, but only as long as the poor stay poor. Thats not a foundation for meaningful change.
Are Toms Shoes All Theyre Cracked Up To Be
Posted on May 30, 2011 by The Modern Gal
I ordered my first pair of trendy TOMS shoes about a year ago, a pair of the classic style made from burlap. Even though I know some people wouldnt agree with me, I like the simple, loafer look of them. Plus, TOMS sells some vegan styles and promises to use earth- and animal-friendly materials whenever possible. The kicker about these kicks, of course, is that for every pair of shoes purchased, TOMS gives a free pair to a child in a need somewhere in the world. When I received my shoes, I was struck by how comfortable they were on top of all the other benefits.
Are they too good to be true?
I started to wonder that after the burlap started to unwravel around the soles after just two weeks of wear. For $54 a pair, I expect my shoes to last far longer than two weeks, and how green can they be and how useful are they to children in developing countries if theyre falling apart that quickly? I did what I do anytime I have questions like this, I turned to The Google to see if others had asked and answered similar questions. What I found were mixed reactions.
Many have complained about the shoes quickly falling apart and have the quality of a $5 pair of shoes. Others have questioned TOMS manufacturing standards, though according to the companys website TOMS requires that the factories operate under sound labor conditions, pay fair wages and follow local labor standards.
Read Also: Removing Mold From Shoes